Philippines’ main coal mine in limbo puts nation’s energy supply at risk
By Cliff Venzon, Bloomberg
Sheila Potestad has spent two decades working as a welder at the Philippines’ largest coal mine on Semirara Island, on the western side of the archipelago. The mother of two is employed there alongside her husband. Now, more than 200 dump trucks, bulldozers and excavators are idle, seawater has forced a shutdown at one site, and the right to operate the mine is up for auction.
“Many rely on the company,” she said. “Parents work here so children will also be affected.”
But what happens next on this remote island matters far beyond the workers who depend on it. Semirara Mining and Power Corp.’s mine produces nearly all of the Philippines’ locally dug coal, supplying about one-fifth of the Southeast Asian nation’s total energy demand. With the current operating agreement due to expire in July next year, a fight over who gets to run the mine — and on what terms — is raising questions over a key source of homegrown power.
About 40% of the 4,000 employees at the 5,500-hectare open pit, where Semirara has operated for nearly three decades, have been retrenched in recent months. Semirara’s parent, DMCI Holdings Inc., took over the mine in the late 1990s after the previous operator struggled to make it viable.
The next operator will be chosen under a bidding process that Semirara has sharply criticized as unfair, including a requirement to surrender more than 55 billion pesos ($863 million) of assets already recovered or depreciated under its existing contract.
Proposals will be evaluated based on the government’s share in the coal business, according to bidding terms published last week by the Department of Energy after several months of delay. Tenders are due Dec. 11, with the award and contract signing scheduled for early January.
Semirara has asked a court to intervene over the terms of the process. The Department of Energy didn’t respond to requests for comment.
“How can you bid under those terms?” Semirara Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Isidro Consunji said last week during a tour of the sprawling mine complex. “What kind of bidding is that? You are disqualifying the existing operator.”
Output at the mine is projected to fall to more than 13 million tons this year from a record 19.9 million tons last year, according to Mr. Consunji, as the company curtails operations eight months before the contract ends.
The company has also started scaling back investment. “We’re not able to buy any capital equipment to increase capacity to solve the seepage problem because you don’t know if it’s [the mine] is still yours or not,” he said.
The situation threatens to leave the Philippines with less locally produced fuel at a time when coal remains its biggest source of grid electricity, generating almost 60% of the total last year despite an aggressive push toward cleaner power.
Energy prices are already among the highest in Southeast Asia and have been pushed up further by the Middle East crisis, which exposed the country’s heavy reliance on imported fuel. A delay or dispute over the auction could increase reliance on coal imports from Indonesia, the Philippines’ top supplier, which has previously considered restricting exports.
“If the transition to a new owner gets messy, disputes over the handover, possible litigation and the loss of operating know-how could disrupt production and efficiency,” said Jasper Timoteo Ondap, an analyst at Regina Capital and Development Corp. “That means less reliable fuel supply for the grid.”
The auction has also drawn political scrutiny.
Member of the House of Representatives Mark Cojuangco criticized the process in a speech last week. “By July of next year, the country could face a severe disruption in domestic coal supply, pushing us head first into a worsening, but avoidable energy crisis,” he said.
Several local interested groups have visited the property since the government opened the bidding, including San Miguel Corp. Asked whether it would bid, San Miguel Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Ramon Ang said, “we always join public bidding.” The conglomerate is known for making jaw-dropping offers to secure projects.
Semirara, which has argued that technical track record should be paramount in the bidding process, will weigh its options, Mr. Consunji said.
Its shares, however, have fallen more than 63% this year amid uncertainty over the contract, making them the worst performer on the Philippine Stock Exchange Index.
For now, some mining continues at a part of the site, although that section’s available coal could run out as soon as this year. A conveyor stretching more than 20 kilometers (12 miles) carries the coal to the island’s port.
Ms. Potestad fears the transition could bring big changes to Semirara Island and leave fewer opportunities for local workers. Still, she hopes that the next operator will keep hiring from the community and bring back people who’ve lost their jobs.
“Everyone is affected,” she said. “Everyone is worried.” — Bloomberg
















